Drill the rivet heads off, then punch the rest of the rivet out of the hole. Remove the seat and install new rivets in the holes. If you're cheap like me, you can grind the ends of the rivet that are inside the boat off, then pull the seat off whats left of the shank of the rivet. Once you get the seat removed, you can rebuck the rivet. I did that with a winchmate on my boat and the rivets sealed back just fine.