Can't say that I have lures I miss as I haven't been roaming the earth long enough for many I started with to go missing. But I have some colors I miss of particular lures and hang on to the ones I have. You would be surprised a lot of the old lures are still made maybe not cheap, but I'm guessing back in the day some of your favorite lures were kind of spendy for the time. What sucks now is rather than acquiring them overtime, your were outed them all at once by some dirt bag, and now realize how much money you had in you box. I try not to think about how much I have in fishing stuff. Like many I don't realize how much I have spent as it has been gradually acquired over time. Think I first started buying fishing stuff since I've been in middle school and first started earning money mowing peoples lawns. As a younger kid I often asked for fishing stuff for birthday/christmas and begged/pleaded for my mom to get tackle before I was able to earn my own money. Now the addiction has turned into a boat, lots of plano tackle tray boxes filled, boxes of extras in the garage from when I've loaded up things that were good deal, enough rods and reels now I've lost count.
Sorry for your loss that sucks. On a different note my favorite lures that have been around for a while are zara spooks, torpedos, jitterbugs, crazy crawlers, and good old floating rapala minnows, still fish old mepps spinners from time to time.