Advantages and disadvantages in "V" , "Mod V" and "Flat Bott

Talk about anything that floats your boat (no pun intended). This is general talk about anything not related to boating/fishing.
Post Reply
printerman
Posts: 11
Joined: 04 Oct 2011, 09:33

Advantages and disadvantages in "V" , "Mod V" and "Flat Bott

Post by printerman » 04 Oct 2011, 11:19

What's the real pro's and con's of hull types ???

User avatar
BaitCaster
Posts: 1608
Joined: 30 Mar 2010, 12:51
Location: Southern Ontario

Advantages and disadvantages in "V" , "Mod V" and "Flat Bott

Post by BaitCaster » 04 Oct 2011, 13:12

Here's my experience. I have a flat-bottom Tracker 1542 riveted Jon. The flat bottom is nice and stable for fishing. The low side-board on the boat is also good for standing and casting. The shallow draft is excellent for skinny waters. In calm water she planes really nice. I also find the flat bottom to be really good for taking the boat camping, as it beaches really nicely.

Despite all of the benefits of the flat-bottom I wish I had gone with a v or modified v (in fact, I am just starting to build a wooden v-bottom skiff). The reason is that I fish in a lot of bigger lakes where the wind can kick up a good chop. Flat bottom boats are not good in choppy water. Also, the low sideboards and transom can make you a little nervous when the water gets rough.

So, the choice really depends on your needs and the waters you fish. if you fish mainly skinny calm waters you can't go wrong with flat bottom. If you plan to take the boat on bigger waters a mod-v or v is the way to go.
“There’s a fine line between fishing and just standing on the shore like an idiot.” ~Stephen Wright

The Livin Large Project - http://www.tinboats.net/forum/viewtopic ... 21&t=14160

User avatar
gouran01
Posts: 355
Joined: 06 Nov 2010, 09:02
Location: Frankenmuth, MI/Browning,IL

Advantages and disadvantages in "V" , "Mod V" and "Flat Bott

Post by gouran01 » 04 Oct 2011, 19:56

two different monsters when comparing my two, but my flat bottom 12 is a terrible beast to fight in 6 inch waves, my 17 ft mod v leaves me with enough comfort to hit 24" + waves when the winds blowin that dang hard.

User avatar
Ranchero50
Moderator
Posts: 1652
Joined: 29 Apr 2009, 14:03
Location: Hagerstown MD

Advantages and disadvantages in "V" , "Mod V" and "Flat Bott

Post by Ranchero50 » 04 Oct 2011, 20:58

I think there's actually four types.

Deep V, think big lake craft, 16-18' high sided Lunds etc. Made for deep water, heavy wave action, tough lake boats.

Low V, think '50-'60's V boat runabouts, 12-16' low sides. Meant for oars or low HP engines, thin hulls, miminal ribs. Not great in deep wave action with the low sides, not tough enough for grinding over rocks etc.

Flat bottom, basic utility or pond boat, blunt nose, no deadrise at the transom, good for flat water, streams, marshes, shallows etc.

Mod V, basic flat bottom with a pointed nose and slight deadrise to handle better at speed vs. a flatbottom.

Under the right conditions any of these types will work in the other styles waters but each type fits different uses better.

Jamie

Post Reply