Question to all

Ice fishing discussions and reports go here.
User avatar
dbelanger24
Posts: 22
Joined: 10 Aug 2013, 11:34
7
Location: Maine

Question to all

Post by dbelanger24 »

Hey guys,

I live up in Maine and am an avid ice fisherman. We almost exclusively fish with 5 ice fishing traps (tip ups), when a fish hits your bait a flag goes up. Just curious why I see a lot of other states almost exclusively jig. I mean, I understand that a lot of people enjoy jigging and it helps you target fish like perch and crappie more effectively. Just find it weird that hardly anyone jigs in Maine and if we do we set 4 tip ups and jig. Do most other states have laws banning tip ups or what?
"A bad day of fishin beats a good day of anything else" :)

User avatar
PA Delaware Fisher
Posts: 117
Joined: 19 Oct 2014, 16:12
6
Location: East Stroudsburg PA

Question to all

Post by PA Delaware Fisher »

I live in Pennsylvania and I use tip ups and a jig pole. It helps pass time while waiting for a flag to pop up. There is a law about how many tip ups you can have out but not that you cant use em.

User avatar
dbelanger24
Posts: 22
Joined: 10 Aug 2013, 11:34
7
Location: Maine

Question to all

Post by dbelanger24 »

Yeah I'm getting the feeling the tip-ups is generally more of a North Eastern thing. I Jig to pass the time occasionally too, but most Mainers gear their traps towards trout, which usually don't strike unless it's live bait swimming on it's own.
PA Delaware Fisher wrote:I live in Pennsylvania and I use tip ups and a jig pole. It helps pass time while waiting for a flag to pop up. There is a law about how many tip ups you can have out but not that you cant use em.
"A bad day of fishin beats a good day of anything else" :)

Gotem
Posts: 122
Joined: 31 Aug 2012, 23:49
8

Question to all

Post by Gotem »

Different places have different regs. NY State is 5 tip-ups and 3 jigging. I believe this is going to change soon to no more than 7 in any combination. More interesting is the NY State law says no more than 5 lures or baits and no more than 15 hook points per line. This was probably set up for trolling with downriggers, but it still applies to ice fishing. This also makes the umbrella rig legal in the summer.

spg
Posts: 43
Joined: 15 Mar 2011, 10:58
10

Question to all

Post by spg »

Any fish can be caught through the ice even trout using a jigging pole and bait or lure. Using only tip-ups is limiting your abaility to catch some extra fish. When you set out tip-ups your restricted to the one hole that it's sitting in. Why not set some tip-ups out and drill some extra holes and jig for active fish. An extra 4 or 5 holes can be used one at a time to check for active fish. With the use of electronics you can see which way the fish want the bait or lure presented. If your catching fish out of one of the holes move a few tip-ups over to that area.

User avatar
muzikman
Donor
Posts: 92
Joined: 23 Aug 2014, 08:56
6
Location: central Michigan

Question to all

Post by muzikman »

Here in Michigan it's 3 lines in any combination.....been that way a while, I believe.

Don't know if it's the same for the U.P. or not....

(That means Upper Penninsula for you non-yoopers LOL)
"Religion is a guy in church thinkin' 'bout fishin';
relationship is a guy out fishin' thinkin' 'bout God."


1983 MIRROCRAFT 14FT
1964 EVINRUDE 3 HP
1975 PFLUEGER M-12 20-SPD
1982 SHORELANDER TADPULL

Milehisnk
Posts: 22
Joined: 27 Aug 2014, 17:14
6
Location: Centennial, CO

Question to all

Post by Milehisnk »

Colorado law is simplified. You can only have 2 rods in the water at any time (with a second rod stamp). Without the stamp, one rod. Doesn't matter if you're ice fishing or casting or trolling.
Current: 1960's Montgomery Ward Sea King 13'6"
Just started...

User avatar
lowe1648
Posts: 180
Joined: 27 Jun 2011, 21:05
9
Location: Mn

Question to all

Post by lowe1648 »

I rarely tip up fish but there are plenty of people here in Minnesota that do. I did make it out this winter once with a fe buddies to chase some flags. We went through 5doz suckers in under 2 hrs. The pike were definitely hungry that day.

User avatar
icepounder
Posts: 58
Joined: 30 Mar 2014, 11:08
7
Location: NJ/NY

Question to all

Post by icepounder »

Here in norther NJ many people use tip ups. Many of my friends do. I personally haven't used them in years. I find it more productive to move until I find active fish and jig. From another hole I will set up a deadstick in a rod holder and use live bait. If the fishing dies off I can start drilling again until I find them. I've seen days where my friends wouldn't get a flag and I limited out.
It's just my style of fishing. I hope everyone had a good ice fishing season !

If you go on youtube and find the video I made about 5-6 weeks ago you can see how I set up. It shows an active jigging hole using my flasher and about 15 feet away my deadstick.
The video is .. Eskimo 6" Silvertip Hand Auger Review
Those who are brave are free ..
1965 Ward Sea King 10' Jon Boat, 2011 Suzuki DF2.5 Outboard

User avatar
jethro
Donor
Posts: 1237
Joined: 25 Jul 2013, 16:12
7
Location: Henniker, NH

Question to all

Post by jethro »

Do you use electronics to fish? Because with a flasher, I can either set up 5 tip ups and catch 10 fish on them all day, or I can use the flasher with my jig stick and catch 10 fish in an hour. The difference is so big it's not even funny.

If I set up tip ups, it's because I am planning on drinking more than fishing. If I'm jigging it's because I actually want to catch fish.
I fish, therefore, I am.

1993 Starcraft SF 14 DLX side console with 25 hp Mercury 2 stroke
2003 Sylvan 2100 Profish walkthrough with 150 Mercury Saltwater and 6hp Mecury 4 stroke kicker

User avatar
onthewater102
Posts: 2200
Joined: 15 Mar 2014, 16:57
7
Location: CT

Question to all

Post by onthewater102 »

jethro wrote:Do you use electronics to fish? Because with a flasher, I can either set up 5 tip ups and catch 10 fish on them all day, or I can use the flasher with my jig stick and catch 10 fish in an hour. The difference is so big it's not even funny.

If I set up tip ups, it's because I am planning on drinking more than fishing. If I'm jigging it's because I actually want to catch fish.
I'm an accountant - so ice season comes and goes while I'm chained to my desk (except for this miserable year...loose ice sheets floating around on opening day in CT...) but from everyone I know that is big into prospecting for fish they all use flashers and a jigging pole, that way they can follow the fish as they drift around under the ice. The guys that target trout and pike tend to use more tip-ups with live bait, but they still have one rod with a jig.

To answer your question - for all the idiotic laws that CT has on the books they are actually pretty relaxed about ice fishing - you're allowed 6 lines total. Personally I think it's excessive, but I'll never suggest they regulate anything more than they already do, but you can tell the small lakes that are hit by the prospectors (drillers for fish) as they tend not to have as many quality bass in them come summer time.

I don't know if it's increased mortality from gut-hooking fish all winter 6 lines at a time, or from their weakness due to their hibernating state under the ice, or if it's just because if you're standing out in the cold trying to pull a fish from the ground you're probably out there because you want to eat it. The cold water fish like pike and trout don't seem to be as affected, but the bass and perch in small lakes where ice fishing are popular all seem to be much smaller. I'm basing that comparison between the fish I catch out of bodies of water that are listed as contaminated and not suitable for eating (where there are no ice-fishermen) vs. similarly sized lakes where consumption is safe and assuming everything else (forage base, ecology etc.) are for the most part similar.
I have a marriage license and a fishing license, but I only carry one in my wallet.

1985 Bass Tracker III

For Sale - Custom Hand Tied Jigs, Bladed Jigs,Custom Rods

2002 Alumacraft 1436LT (SOLD)

User avatar
bassin_da_U.P.
Posts: 7
Joined: 31 Mar 2015, 19:55
6
Location: Gladstone, Mi.

Question to all

Post by bassin_da_U.P. »

muzikman wrote:Here in Michigan it's 3 lines in any combination.....been that way a while, I believe.

Don't know if it's the same for the U.P. or not....

(That means Upper Penninsula for you non-yoopers LOL)

It's the same rules up here as it is for you down below the bridge eh. We usually set two tip ups and jig one.

User avatar
muzikman
Donor
Posts: 92
Joined: 23 Aug 2014, 08:56
6
Location: central Michigan

Question to all

Post by muzikman »

Hey, Gladstone! Good to hear from ya up there!

Fished in the Little Bay many times past out of Escanaba...

...always a good time.

Well, except for the one time in April years ago - cold, rainy, windy....wind & waves almost laid our boat on its side out there! Got too far out into the big lake, it seems. Scared the **** outta me for a minute or two....LOL

Gotta get back up there soon to see how Fayette is coming along, also! Been quite a few years since.
"Religion is a guy in church thinkin' 'bout fishin';
relationship is a guy out fishin' thinkin' 'bout God."


1983 MIRROCRAFT 14FT
1964 EVINRUDE 3 HP
1975 PFLUEGER M-12 20-SPD
1982 SHORELANDER TADPULL

User avatar
bassin_da_U.P.
Posts: 7
Joined: 31 Mar 2015, 19:55
6
Location: Gladstone, Mi.

Question to all

Post by bassin_da_U.P. »

muzikman wrote:Hey, Gladstone! Good to hear from ya up there!

Fished in the Little Bay many times past out of Escanaba...

...always a good time.

Well, except for the one time in April years ago - cold, rainy, windy....wind & waves almost laid our boat on its side out there! Got too far out into the big lake, it seems. Scared the **** outta me for a minute or two....LOL

Gotta get back up there soon to see how Fayette is coming along, also! Been quite a few years since.

Yep the weather changes quickly that's for sure. It's funny you mention boating in April, heck there is still ice across the bay in Gladstone. I still see some people going out Ice fishing.

User avatar
muzikman
Donor
Posts: 92
Joined: 23 Aug 2014, 08:56
6
Location: central Michigan

Question to all

Post by muzikman »

Yeah - definitely been a cold one this winter for us...taking a L-O-N-G time for things to finally thaw out.
"Religion is a guy in church thinkin' 'bout fishin';
relationship is a guy out fishin' thinkin' 'bout God."


1983 MIRROCRAFT 14FT
1964 EVINRUDE 3 HP
1975 PFLUEGER M-12 20-SPD
1982 SHORELANDER TADPULL